Player Batting Comparison Finder

Data runs from 1871 to 2020. Stats relying on play-by-play data are complete back to 1973, mostly complete back to 1950, and somewhat complete back to 1916.

Current Search      

Elmer Flick (1906) vs. Edd Roush (1923) vs. Tony Gwynn (1990) vs. Fred Clarke (1903) vs. Ginger Beaumont (1907) vs. Jack Tobin (1922)
Display Query »
   select                                 player_ID,
                name_common as player,
                CONCAT('/players/',LOWER(LEFT(bio.player_ID,1)),'/',bio.player_ID,'.shtml') as player_link,
                year_ID,
                min(year_ID) as year_min,
                max(year_ID) as year_max,
                if(min(year_ID)=max(year_ID), (IF(birth_baseball,year_ID - birth_baseball, NULL)), (IF(birth_baseball,concat(min(year_ID-birth_baseball),'-',max(year_ID-birth_baseball)), NULL))) as age,

                SUM(a.G) AS G, SUM(a.PA) AS PA, SUM(a.AB) AS AB, SUM(a.R) AS R, SUM(a.H) AS H, SUM(a.H - (a.2B + a.3B + a.HR)) as 1B, SUM(a.2B) AS 2B, SUM(a.3B) AS 3B, SUM(a.HR) AS HR, SUM(a.RBI) AS RBI, SUM(a.SB) AS SB, SUM(a.CS) AS CS, SUM(a.BB) AS BB, SUM(a.SO) AS SO,
ROUND(IF(SUM(a.AB) = 0, NULL, ROUND(SUM(a.H)  / SUM(a.AB),10)),3) as batting_avg, ROUND(IF(SUM(a.AB + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0) + IFNULL(a.SF,0)) = 0, NULL, ROUND(SUM(a.H + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0)) / SUM(a.AB + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0) + IFNULL(a.SF,0)),10)),3) as onbase_perc, ROUND(IF(SUM(a.AB) = 0, NULL, ROUND(SUM(a.H + a.2B + (2 * a.3B) + (3 * a.HR)) / SUM(a.AB), 10)),3) as slugging_perc, ROUND(IF(SUM(a.AB + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0) + IFNULL(a.SF,0)) = 0, NULL, ROUND(SUM(a.H + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0)) / SUM(a.AB + IFNULL(a.BB,0) + IFNULL(a.HBP,0) + IFNULL(a.SF,0)),10)) + IF(SUM(a.AB) = 0, NULL, ROUND(SUM(a.H + a.2B + (2 * a.3B) + (3 * a.HR)) / SUM(a.AB), 10)),3) as onbase_plus_slugging ,
SUM(a.H + a.2B + (2 * a.3B) + (3 * a.HR)) AS TB, if(sum(a.GIDP is null and AB is not null)/count(*) < .30, SUM(a.GIDP), null) AS GIDP, SUM(a.HBP) AS HBP, SUM(a.SH) AS SH, SUM(a.SF) AS SF, SUM(a.IBB) AS IBB


     from post_batting a
     join bio using (player_ID)
     
    where player_ID=? and year_ID >= ? and year_ID <= ? and team_ID != 'TOT'
 group by player_ID
Show Criteria

Search Criteria

Click on the red text to pre-fill the form with various values

Player 1
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Tony Gwynn 
Player 2
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Ginger Beaumont 
Player 3
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Fred Clarke 
Player 4
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Edd Roush 
Player 5
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Jack Tobin 
Player 6
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Elmer Flick 

You have edited your search criteria

or keep editing your search

clear changes

Standard

Standard
Rk Name Year Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB OPS+
1Elmer Flick190630157704624981943422162395465.311.372.441.813275715155
2Edd Roush19233013859252788185411868810154616.351.406.531.938280316148
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Value

Value
Rk Name Year Age G PA Rbat Rbaser Rdp Rfield Rpos RAA WAA Rrep RAR WAR waaWL% 162WL% oWAR dWAR oRAR Salary
1Elmer Flick19063015770436102-6334.023576.5.525.5246.2-0.455
2Edd Roush19233013859237-30-2-4282.718474.6.520.5174.8-0.549
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Advanced

Advanced
Rk Name Year Age Outs RC RC/G AIR BAbip BA lgBA OBP lgOBP SLG lgSLG OPS lgOPS OPS+ OWn% BtRuns BtWins TotA SecA ISO PwrSpd
1Elmer Flick1906304451016.074.346.311.255.372.310.441.326.813.637155.75939.24.5.872.279.1302.0
2Edd Roush1923303731087.8105.354.351.291.406.349.531.405.938.754148.71236.23.5.950.258.1807.5
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Win Probability

Win Probability
Rk Name Year Age BtRuns BtWins Plays WPA WPA+ WPA- aLI WPA/LI Clutch cWPA cWPA+ cWPA- acLI cClutch RE24 REW boLI RE24/boLI PHlev AB
1Elmer Flick19063039.24.5
2Edd Roush19233036.23.55833.512.7-9.2%1.082.31.05.8%24.6%-18.8%3.630.3%28.52.80.9826.80.812
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Ratio

Ratio
Rk Name Year Age HR% SO% BB% XBH% X/H% SO/W AB/SO AB/HR AB/RBI GB/FB GO/AO IP% LD% HR/FB IF/FB
1Elmer Flick1906300.1%9.2%7.7%8.1%29%1.209.6624.010.179%
2Edd Roush1923301.0%2.7%7.8%11.0%35%0.3532.987.86.01.0185%
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Baserunning

Baserunning
Rk Name Year Age ROE XI RS% SBO SB CS SB% SB2 CS2 SB3 CS3 SBH CSH PO PCS OOB OOB1 OOB2 OOB3 OOBHm BT XBT% 1stS 1stS2 1stS3 1stD 1stD3 1stDH 2ndS 2ndS3 2ndSH
1Elmer Flick1906300038%39
2Edd Roush1923309036%240101540%612003341161546949%40261396332724
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Situational

Situational
Hits Pinch Hitting Home Runs SH GIDP PrdOut BaseRunners Advances
Rk Name Year Age PA Ptn% H Inf Bnt AB H HR RBI PHlev All GS GSo vRH vLH Hm Rd IP Att Suc % Opp DP % Opp Suc % BR BRS BRS% <2,3B Scr % 0,2B Adv % PAu
1Elmer Flick190630194115
2Edd Roush19233055683.5%18521000.816084115016112492551.0%3717319.7%412868.3%201260.0%36
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Pitches

Pitches
Rk Name Year Age PA Pit Pit/PA Str Str% L/Str S/Str F/Str I/Str AS/Str I/Bll AS/Pit Con 1stS 30% 30c 30s 20% 20c 20s 31% 31c 31s L/SO S/SO L/SO% PAu Pitu Stru
1Elmer Flick190630
2Edd Roush192330
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Postseason

Postseason
Rk Name Year Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB
1Fred Clarke19033083534392102115.265.286.382.66813000
If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.