Player Pitching Comparison Finder

Data runs from 1871 to 2020. Stats relying on play-by-play data are complete back to 1973, mostly complete back to 1950, and somewhat complete back to 1916.

Current Search      

Willie McGill (1894) vs. Mike Smith (1888) vs. Bob Feller (1939) vs. Ice Box Chamberlain (1888) vs. Nat Hudson (1889) vs. Scott Stratton (1890)

Search Criteria

Click on the red text to pre-fill the form with various values

Player 1
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Bob Feller 
Season (of player's career)
Player 2
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Nat Hudson 
Season (of player's career)
Player 3
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Ice Box Chamberlain 
Season (of player's career)
Player 4
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Mike Smith 
Season (of player's career)
Player 5
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Scott Stratton 
Season (of player's career)
Player 6
Javascript is required for the selection of a player.
Choice is: Willie McGill 
Season (of player's career)

You have edited your search criteria

or keep editing your search

clear changes

Standard

Standard
Rk Name Year Age W L W-L% ERA G GS GF CG SHO SV IP H R ER HR BB IBB SO HBP BK WP BF WHIP H9 HR9 BB9 SO9 SO/W
1Willie McGill189420719.2695.84272332200208.027219513521175810069981.87011.80.15.12.50.50
2Mike Smith1888202217.5642.74404003750348.13091671061891541902514561.1438.00.02.34.01.73
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Value

Value
Rk Name Year Age IP G GS R RA9 RA9opp RA9def RA9role RA9extras PPFp RA9avg RAA WAA gmLI WAAadj WAR RAR waaWL% 162WL% Salary
1Willie McGill189420208.027231958.447.35-0.390.00105.08.1300.01.00-0.21.826.500.500
2Mike Smith188820348.140401674.315.160.260.00101.04.95272.6-0.54.347.566.516
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Win Probability

Win Probability
Rk Name Year Age PtchR PtchW Plays WPA WPA+ WPA- aLI WPA/LI Clutch RE24 REW boLI RE24/boLI LevHi LevMd LevLo
1Willie McGill189420-5.5-0.4
2Mike Smith18882018.21.7
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Ratio

Ratio
Rk Name Year Age Ptn% HR% SO% BB% SO-BB% XBH% X/H% GB/FB GO/AO IP% LD% HR/FB IF/FB Opp DP % PAu
1Willie McGill1894200.2%5.8%11.7%-5.9%
2Mike Smith1888200.1%10.6%6.1%4.5%
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Batting Against

Batting Against
Rk Name Year Age PAu G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS BAbip TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB ROE
1Willie McGill1894202799819527221175810
2Mike Smith18882040145616730918915419
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Pitches

Pitches
Rk Name Year Age PA Pit Pit/PA Str Str% L/Str S/Str F/Str I/Str AS/Str I/Bll AS/Pit Con 1st% 30% 30c 30s 02% 02c 02s 02h L/SO S/SO L/SO% 3pK 4pW PAu Pitu Stru
1Willie McGill189420
2Mike Smith188820
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Base Situation

Base Situation
Hits Home Runs Advances Batting Stats
Rk Name Year Age PA H Inf Bnt All GS GSo vRH vLH Hm Rd <2,3B Scr SO % ROE WP PB SBO SB CS SB% SB2 CS2 SB3 CS3 SBH CSH PO PCS BT PAu
1Willie McGill18942027226
2Mike Smith188820309125
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Starter

Starter
Rk Name Year Age G GS Wgs Lgs ND Wchp Ltuf Wtm Ltm tmW-L% Wlst Lsv CG SHO QS QS% GmScA Best Wrst BQR BQS sDR lDR RS/GS RS/IP IP/GS Pit/GS <80 80-99 100-119 ≥120 Max
1Willie McGill1894202723220
2Mike Smith1888204040375
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Reliever

Reliever
Rk Name Year Age G GR GF Wgr Lgr SVOpp SV BSv SV% SVSit Hold IR IS IS% 1stIP aLI LevHi LevMd LevLo Ahd Tie Bhd Runr Empt >3o <3o IPmult 0DR Out/GR Pit/GR
1Willie McGill1894202730
2Mike Smith1888204000
Full results available for Stathead subscribers. Subscribe or log in.
4
5
6

Postseason

Postseason
Rk Name Year Age W L W-L% ERA G GS GF CG SHO SV IP H R ER HR BB IBB SO HBP BK WP BF WHIP H9 HR9 BB9 SO9 SO/W
1Ice Box Chamberlain18882023.4005.3255051044.0523626316131.54510.60.63.32.70.81
2Scott Stratton18902011.5002.3733110019.0261550481.57912.30.01.93.82.00
If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.