Player Batting Comparison: Ty Cobb vs. Miguel Cabrera vs. Al Kaline vs. Alan Trammell

NEW: Sample Searches for learning more about the power and flexibility of Stathead. • Data runs from 1871 to present. Stats relying on play-by-play data are complete back to 1973, mostly complete back to 1950, and somewhat complete back to 1915. Postseason data for AL/NL runs from 1903 to present.

Current Search

Compare player statistics for: Ty Cobb for 1912-1921 vs. Miguel Cabrera for 2008-2017 vs. Al Kaline for 1960-1969 vs. Alan Trammell for 1984-1992.

Show Criteria

Compare single seasons or full career
Ex. Compare full careers or single seasons for up to six players

Compare group of seasons
Ex. Compare multiple combined seasons for up to six players

Search Criteria

Click on the red text to pre-fill the form with various values

Player 1

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Choice is: Ty Cobb

to

Player 2

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Choice is: Miguel Cabrera

to

Player 3

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Choice is: Al Kaline

to

Player 4

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Choice is: Alan Trammell

to

Player 5

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Type name to select an option

Player 6

Javascript is required for the selection of a player.

Type name to select an option

You have edited your search criteria

or keep editing your search

Fetching Results

Standard

Standard
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	OPS+
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	1288	5638	4875	1006	1846	296	148	45	773	465	138	608	289	.379	.452	.528	.979	2573		39	104			182
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	1506	6458	5628	922	1794	362	7	324	1090	21	10	743	1034	.319	.398	.558	.957	3142	207	35	0	52	156	156
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	1322	5473	4730	811	1399	247	31	210	772	73	23	652	489	.296	.381	.494	.875	2338	122	25	20	46	65	141
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	1115	4832	4282	646	1239	230	28	120	573	121	52	440	427	.289	.356	.440	.796	1885	79	26	42	41	35	120

Value

Value
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	G	PA	Rbat	Rbaser	Rdp	Rfield	Rpos	RAA	WAA	Rrep	RAR	WAR	waaWL%	162WL%	oWAR	dWAR	oRAR	Salary
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	1288	5638	500	27	0	-16	-34	478	51.7	206	683	73.0	.540	.533	75.0	-5.7	699	$180,333
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	1506	6458	414	-12	-26	-54	-62	260	28.1	234	494	50.7	.518	.517	56.1	-11.1	548	$207,683,049
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	1322	5473	267	23	-6	65	-45	304	31.3	172	475	48.7	.525	.521	43.6	0.8	411	$559,000
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	1115	4832	129	12	7	71	66	286	29.6	164	450	45.0	.526	.522	37.9	14.6	378	$10,201,429

Advanced

Advanced
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	Outs	RC	RC/G	AIR	BAbip	BA	lgBA	OBP	lgOBP	SLG	lgSLG	OPS	lgOPS	OPS+	OWn%	BtRuns	BtWins	TotA	SecA	ISO	PwrSpd
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	3271	1156	9.5	90	.397	.379	.268	.452	.339	.528	.356	.979	.694	182	.841	529.2	56.6	1.164	.341	.149	82.1
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	4103	1225	8.0	102	.340	.319	.261	.398	.327	.558	.417	.957	.744	156	.727	459.9	44.3	.973	.374	.240	39.4
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	3542	908	6.9	97	.292	.296	.258	.381	.329	.494	.395	.875	.725	141	.714	275.8	28.5	.888	.347	.199	108.3
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	3257	693	5.7	97	.296	.289	.260	.356	.326	.440	.398	.796	.724	120	.6	123.0	11.9	.779	.270	.151	120.5

Win Probability

Win Probability
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	BtRuns	BtWins	Plays	WPA	WPA+	WPA-	aLI	WPA/LI	Clutch	cWPA	cWPA+	cWPA-	acLI	cClutch	RE24	REW	boLI	RE24/boLI	PHlev	AB
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	529.2	56.6	1820	13.4	39.2	-25.7	1.05	11.1	1.7	17.3%	47.9%	-30.6%	2.10	2.7%	137.7	14.5	0.99	123.2	2.12	6
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	459.9	44.3	6582	42.5	145.2	-102.7	.99	43.7	-0.7	32.3%	105.0%	-72.7%	1.17	1.9%	433.5	41.4	0.95	489.3	2.70	11
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	275.8	28.5	5652	36.3	122.9	-86.6	1.03	37.4	-2.0	47.4%	154.3%	-106.9%	2.15	4.2%	351.4	35.5	0.94	392.1	2.20	57
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	123.0	11.9	5086	15.9	96.0	-80.1	1.01	12.2	3.5	20.3%	84.6%	-64.3%	1.42	7.2%	146.2	14.3	0.97	131.7	2.41	18

Ratio

Ratio
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	HR%	SO%	BB%	XBH%	X/H%	SO/W	AB/SO	AB/HR	AB/RBI	GB/FB	GO/AO	IP%	LD%	HR/FB	IF/FB
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	0.8%	5.1%	10.8%	8.7%	27%	0.48	16.9	108.3	6.3		1.39	81%
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	5.0%	16.0%	11.5%	10.7%	39%	1.39	5.4	17.4	5.2	0.73	1.05	67%	25%	13.3%	9%
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	3.8%	8.9%	11.9%	8.9%	35%	0.75	9.7	22.5	6.1		0.76	74%
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	2.5%	8.8%	9.1%	7.8%	31%	0.97	10.0	35.7	7.5	0.62	0.69	78%	25%	5.2%	22%

Baserunning

Baserunning
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	ROE	XI	RS%	SBO	SB	CS	SB%	SB2	CS2	SB3	CS3	SBH	CSH	PO	PCS	OOB	OOB1	OOB2	OOB3	OOBHm	BT	XBT%	1stS	1stS2	1stS3	1stD	1stD3	1stDH	2ndS	2ndS3	2ndSH
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	33	0	39%	540	466	137		90	35	19	10	1	4	26	2	70	4	14	26	26	53	64%	85	25	47	21	7	12	68	12	53
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	44	0	27%	2665	21	10	68%	16	6	5	4	0	0	0	0	67	7	30	13	17	168	32%	452	345	102	110	78	30	215	93	114
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	88	0	32%	2127	73	23	76%	65	18	8	3	0	2	2	0	52	2	21	13	16	156	60%	279	127	148	79	39	35	179	34	137
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	70	1	33%	1900	121	52	70%	112	45	9	6	0	1	11	3	37	5	9	10	13	167	53%	261	150	110	55	32	23	161	34	121

Situational

Situational
							Hits			Pinch Hitting					Home Runs								SH			GIDP			PrdOut			BaseRunners			Advances
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	PA	Ptn%	H	Inf	Bnt	AB	H	HR	RBI	PHlev	All	GS	GSo	vRH	vLH	Hm	Rd	IP	Att	Suc	%	Opp	DP	%	Opp	Suc	%	BR	BRS	BRS%	<2,3B	Scr	%	0,2B	Adv	%	PAu
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34	1614	74.5%	1846			6	2	0	2	2.12	45	0	57	11	2	9	23	3		104		337			128	58	45.3%	1094	217	19.8%	107	67	62.6%	66	41	62.1%	2495
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	6458	25.1%	1794	84	0	11	3	0	2	2.70	324	3	133	256	68	166	158	0	0	0		1345	207	15.4%	533	188	35.3%	4204	791	18.8%	421	225	53.4%	278	173	62.2%	0
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34	5473	30.7%	1399			57	22	1	15	2.20	210	1	87	136	74	120	90	1	29	20	69.0%	1185	122	10.3%	426	139	32.6%	3430	581	16.9%	321	176	54.8%	197	110	55.8%	0
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	4832	33.2%	1239	60	9	18	5	0	4	2.41	120	2	104	71	49	59	61	0	53	42	79.3%	1029	79	7.7%	503	164	32.6%	3110	479	15.4%	271	151	55.7%	210	110	52.4%	0

Pitches

Pitches
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	PA	Pit	Pit/PA	Str	Str%	L/Str	S/Str	F/Str	I/Str	AS/Str	I/Bll	AS/Pit	Con	1stS	30%	30c	30s	20%	20c	20s	31%	31c	31s	L/SO	S/SO	L/SO%	PAu	Pitu	Stru
1	Ty Cobb	1912	1921	25-34
2	Miguel Cabrera	2008	2017	25-34	6464	24079	3.73	14796	62.9%	21.2%	17.1%	30.4%	31.4%	78.8%	5.9%	49.6%	78.3%	36.4%	6.7%	435	34	16.1%	1038	371	8.2%	529	286	200	834	19.3%	0	0	0
3	Al Kaline	1960	1969	25-34
4	Alan Trammell	1984	1992	26-34	2160	7713	3.57	4584	59.8%	31.0%	8.3%	22.4%	38.2%	68.8%	1.6%	41.2%	87.9%	20.1%	7.4%	160	8	19.6%	424	159	10.4%	224	126	60	126	32.3%	47	1	5

Postseason

Postseason
Rk	Name	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	Miguel Cabrera	2011	2014	28-31	38	161	137	18	39	8	0	9	26	3	0	23	29	.285	.391	.540	.931	74	5	1	0	0	7
2	Al Kaline	1968	1968	33	7	30	29	6	11	2	0	2	8	0	0	0	7	.379	.400	.655	1.055	19	0	1	0	0	0
3	Alan Trammell	1984	1987	26-29	13	58	51	10	17	2	1	3	11	1	1	6	5	.333	.404	.588	.992	30	2	0	1	0	0

If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.